Picture a small business owner in Albany who has just been given the name of an accounting firm by a colleague. Before dialing, she types the firm’s name into Google and reads the first reviews and whatever the firm wrote under them. Nothing in that moment involves the firm, and it decides whether the phone rings. This hypothetical shows where trust is won or lost for professional firms: in the review section, before any conversation starts.
The result to aim for: reviews that earn the call
Referrals do not skip Google. Scorpion’s 2025 Legal Consumer Trends Report found that 74% of legal clients research a firm online after a referral. The 2024 U.S. Consumer Legal Needs Survey from Thomson Reuters and FindLaw, a poll of 2,000 adults, found that 82% of respondents who contacted an attorney after learning about them online used online reviews. Both figures describe legal clients. No comparable figure for accountants, engineers or consultants was found, so for those firms read the numbers as a signal, not a measurement.
Albany had 99,224 residents at the 2020 Census (US Census Bureau, 2020). In a city that size, referrals are likely a common route to a firm, and each one can pass through a Google check. Reviews appear next to your Business Profile in Maps and Search, so the goal here is a review section that gives a careful reader a reason to call.
Step 1: read your reviews as a stranger would
Run this audit before you change anything:
- Search your firm’s name on Google, then select Reviews in the results.
- Read the five most recent reviews and the replies under them, as someone who has never heard of you.
- Mark every review with no reply, and every reply that names the reviewer’s matter or confirms the reviewer was a client.
- Mark replies that sound defensive, or that repeat the same sentences under different reviews.
- Write one line on what a stranger would conclude about how your firm handles disagreement.
Do it once in Search and once in Maps, since Google shows reviews in both places.
Step 2: reply so the next reader sees how you handle conflict
A negative review is not the main risk. Google says negative reviews are not necessarily a sign of poor practice, and that an honest mix of positive and negative feedback can feel more trustworthy to prospects. The damage comes from the reply: a defensive paragraph, no answer at all, or the same text pasted under every complaint. Each reply is public and can reach many later readers, not only the reviewer. That is reasoning from Google’s guidance, not a measured result.
Replying requires a verified profile. The reviewer is notified when you reply and can still change the review afterward. Google’s own tips ask for a conversational tone rather than a promotion, an apology where one is due, a signature with your name or initials, and an invitation to continue by phone or email. You do not need to thank every reviewer publicly.
Hypothetical reply to a review about slow communication: Thank you for the feedback about response times. You expected an update and did not get one, and we will look at how we handle that. Please call the office so I can hear the details. Dana, managing partner. It names no matter, makes no promise about an outcome and ends with a way to talk offline.
Step 3: collect reviews from every client, inside Google’s rules
Google lets you create a link or QR code for customers and suggests placing it in thank-you emails, at the end of a chat or on receipts. For a firm, the natural place is the closing email when an engagement ends. Send it to every client, not a hand-picked few. Google’s policy lists discouraging negative reviews or selectively soliciting positive ones as prohibited, and it also prohibits payment, discounts or free services in exchange for a review. It does not allow merchants to pressure people to review while on the premises, or to ask staff for a set number of reviews.
Reviews must reflect a genuine experience. A review written by an employee or a friend of the firm is a conflict of interest under Google’s policy, so it is a risk and not a shortcut.
Step 4: keep replies steady and check the result each month
A firm with several partners tends to answer reviews in the voice of whoever is on duty, and a reader sees that as inconsistency. Agree on who replies, how quickly, and on three rules: no client details, no argument, an offer to talk offline. Google advises responding in a timely manner.
For the drafting itself, review reply drafts in LocalEdge Lite let AVI write a draft for each review, and you read and edit it before it goes out. Agencies that look after professional clients can use reply suggestions for agency client profiles, including replies in bulk, and should keep a person reading each one before it is sent.
Once a month, repeat the five-step audit and compare it with the last one. For the profile around the reviews, read our complete guide to Google Business Profile and local SEO in New York State.
Which review would you want the next prospect in Albany to read first? Start free with LocalEdge Lite; no card is needed.