Picture a patient standing outside an old office on Delaware Avenue, phoning the front desk to ask where the practice went. The Google profile may already show the new address. The old one is often somewhere else, and finding it takes a method more than a single edit.
One survey of US consumers found that 22% had visited the wrong location in the previous year because a business address was incorrect online. It is an old survey covering all business types, so read it as a sign of the risk, not as a Buffalo measurement.
The short answer: an old address can survive in a duplicate practice listing, in a separate listing for an individual dentist, on a map pin and in directories, so editing the main profile fixes only one of them. The steps below find each copy and fix it according to its type. For the wider picture of the state, see our complete guide to New York State local SEO.
Where an old address survives after a dental practice moves
A dental practice usually leaves several address traces, because one suite can be listed under more than one name.
- The practice listing from before the move. A duplicate created at opening, by a former partner or by an earlier marketing vendor can still carry the old street and the old phone number.
- A listing for an individual dentist. Google can hold a profile for Dr. Name, DDS, separate from the practice, and it keeps the old suite until someone edits it.
- A specialty listing. An orthodontist or periodontist who works inside a general practice may have a profile under their own category.
- A map pin on the old building, even when the written address is correct.
- Directories, carrier search pages and booking tools that copied the data years ago.
Take a practice that leaves Elmwood Village or Allentown for an office in Amherst or Orchard Park. This is a made-up example, but the pattern is easy to see: the main profile gets edited and the other places keep pointing to the old block.
Run searches that expose every old listing
You find stale listings by searching for what stays unchanged in old data: the previous address, the previous phone number and each dentist’s name.
- Open Google Maps in a signed-out browser window and search the old street address. Note every result at that address, including listings that look inactive.
- Search the old phone number. A duplicate can still carry it even when the address was edited.
- Search each dentist by name, then by name plus the word Buffalo. Check whether a separate listing exists for each dentist and for each specialist who practices in your suite.
- Search the practice name and every former name, including a name that contained a partner who has left.
- Open each result and record the name, address, phone number, category and whether it shows a Claim this business link, which suggests that nobody manages it.
- Zoom in on the pin of your live profile and confirm that it sits on the right building.
Keep the findings in a simple sheet with one row per listing and a column for the fix you chose. That sheet becomes the checklist in the last section.
Fix each listing according to what it is
The right fix depends on whether the listing is yours, a duplicate, or someone else’s.
A listing you manage
Edit the address inside the profile, through Edit profile and then Business information; the exact labels in Google’s interface change from time to time. Google may ask you to verify the practice again after an address change, so plan for that step before you tell patients the move is complete.
Leave the live profile open. A listing marked permanently closed still appears on Maps, so a patient can read it as a closure of the practice and not as a move.
Practices that want the address watched afterwards can look at Guardian, an optional add-on that checks the profile through the Google API every hour and alerts within the hour with the field, the old value, the new value and a Fix Now button. It is described on the page for LocalEdge plans for single practices.
A duplicate you cannot edit
Open the listing in Google Maps, select Suggest an edit, then Close or remove. Google Maps Help lists options there that include Duplicate of another place, Permanently closed and Moved to a new location (Google Maps Help, 2026). For a copy of a practice that still operates, Duplicate of another place describes the situation; Moved to a new location fits an old office that the practice has left.
If a former partner or vendor claimed the duplicate, ask that person to edit or release it, then contact Business Profile support and ask them to review the duplicate. Keep the row in your sheet open until the listing is gone from Maps in a signed-out window.
An old listing that holds the reviews
When the old address sits on the listing that holds the patient reviews and the new listing holds none, closing the old one throws away the reviews that patients can read. Edit the address on the listing with the reviews, then treat the empty one as the duplicate.
Directories, carriers and the state license record
Old public information can keep an old address alive. A Google help update of September 2026 says that owners are notified of some suggested edits and have four days to accept or refuse them, and that Google can publish an edit backed by public information (Search Engine Roundtable, 2026). Logically, an outdated directory entry is public information too, so correct the directories you can reach as well as the profile.
Work through your website footer and contact page, your scheduling tool, your social profiles, the main directories and the provider directories of the dental carriers you contract with. Ask each carrier how it takes address updates. Use one format everywhere: same suite number, same spelling of Avenue, same phone number.
The state license record is a separate list. New York requires licensees to tell the State Education Department about a mailing address change within 30 days of the change (NYSED Office of the Professions, 2026). Its licensing statistics count 676 dentists in Erie County as of January 1, 2026, by primary mailing address on record, which the Office says is not necessarily the practice address (NYSED Office of the Professions, 2026). Both points concern licensing, not Google, and what applies to your situation is a question for the Office of the Professions.
Keep a checklist so the address stays fixed
- One row per listing in the sheet, each with a person responsible and the date it was last checked.
- A signed-out Maps search for the old address and the old phone number after every fix.
- A review of the dentist and specialist listings whenever a provider joins or leaves the suite.
- Website, scheduling tool and social profiles updated in the same sitting as the profile.
- The mailing address on the state license record confirmed with the Office of the Professions.
- A fresh search of Maps after the directories you contacted have had time to refresh.
Agencies that inherit dental clients from a previous vendor can use the same sheet as an intake step for each practice. LocalEdge for agencies managing dental clients includes a dashboard of all clients and the optional Guardian add-on with bulk activation. For a second look at one profile after the cleanup, the LocalEdge scan for single practices is one option.
Which listing at your practice still carries the old address: the practice, a dentist or a directory? LocalEdge Lite is free, needs no card, gives a GBP Score from 0 to 100 across more than 15 criteria and includes a 15-day Guardian trial: start with the free LocalEdge Lite.