A solicitor in Manchester checks the firm’s ranking from a desk at the office, sees the profile among the first results and treats the question as settled. A prospective client searching from another part of the city sees a different firm first. Both observations are correct, and the gap between them is what a single ranking figure hides.
The sections below take the problem apart as three possible causes, then give a test a firm or an agency can run. For the wider picture of how heatmaps work across the country, see our complete guide to UK Google Maps heatmaps.
The symptom: one firm, different results a few blocks apart
Google states that local results rest on relevance, distance and prominence, and it does not publish the weights. Distance is measured from the searcher, or from the location typed into the search, so two people looking for the same service from different streets start from different points.
That is the symptom in its plainest form. A firm reports a strong position when the check is made from its own door, and a weaker one, or none at all, a short distance away. Neither number is wrong. Each describes one point on the map.
Cause 1: distance is measured from the searcher, not the office
Take a hypothetical firm near Deansgate. A person searching from the city centre may see it among the first results, while someone searching from Didsbury is closer to other firms and may see those instead. The firm has not changed between the two searches. The searcher’s position has.
This matters for law firms because clients may search from home, from work or from a train, and the result they see depends on that spot. A ranking checked at the office measures one point, and that point may not match where clients actually search.
Cause 2: the practice area changes what counts as relevant
A firm that handles conveyancing, employment and family matters does not compete in one market. Each search wording brings a different set of rival profiles, and the firm can appear on a block for one practice area and be absent for another.
The primary category and the services listed on the profile tell Google what the firm is relevant for, so they deserve a deliberate choice, not the default. Choose the category that describes the main work, add secondary categories for services the firm actually offers, and none beyond them, and check the result against the wording a client would type. The wording of the profile should stay factual and avoid any promise of an outcome, which is especially important in a regulated field. The firm should check the advertising and marketing rules that apply to it before publishing claims.
Cause 3: crowded blocks reward prominence
In a dense part of the city, many firms compete for the same searches, and prominence becomes the tiebreaker. Prominence includes reviews and what Google finds about the firm elsewhere. Google’s guidance rules out offering incentives for reviews and selecting satisfied clients to ask for one, so the usable approach is a consistent, plain request to every client at a suitable moment.
Replies deserve care. A firm should agree with its compliance lead how to answer reviews without confirming who is, or is not, a client. Cause 3 explains why a firm can look strong on a quiet block and ordinary on a crowded one, even though the profile is identical.
How to run a block test
The test turns a single reading into a map. Do it by hand first, then with a grid scan.
- Choose three searches that match the firm’s main services, written as a client would type them.
- Pick several points around the firm and in the neighbourhoods it wants to serve, such as the city centre, Salford Quays and Didsbury.
- At each point, run the three searches on a phone in Google Maps and note where the firm appears, or that it does not.
- Mark each point as strong, weak or absent, and look for the pattern.
- Repeat after any change to the profile, so the result is judged on what moved.
A grid scan does the same job from many more points. LocalEdge Solo offers a heatmap of up to 21×21 points with 5 keywords per scan, and grid scans for a single law firm are described on the scan page. LocalEdge Lite has no heatmap.
Read the pattern with a few rules:
- If the firm is strong at the office and weak elsewhere, the profile serves its immediate area, and wider visibility needs work on category, services and reviews.
- If it is weak for a single practice area, review the categories and services for that work.
- If it is weak in a crowded block, compare the reviews and profile detail of nearby firms before changing anything.
Fix, then keep the profile accurate
Corrections to categories, services and review handling are slow to show, so keep a record of what changed and when. Guardian, an optional LocalEdge add-on, checks the profile every hour and alerts within the hour when a field such as the phone number or the opening hours changes, showing the old and new values. It is not instant, and it does not prevent the change.
For agencies, LocalEdge Agency supports scheduled scans (daily, weekly or monthly) with history and evolution, and it can overlay competitors on the grid. The PDF reports have configurable sections, including Heatmap and Competitors, and can be sent weekly by e-mail to each client. The agency page with scheduled scans and reports lists the full set, and the Lite and Solo plans for UK firms cover single firms.
As a next step, check where the profile stands before running any test. LocalEdge Lite is free, needs no card and gives a GBP Score from 0 to 100 on more than 15 criteria, which points to the gaps worth fixing first: check your GBP Score with LocalEdge Lite.